Caramel Pumpkin Pie

Caramel Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin pie - the shy wallflower of the pie set.

It looks pretty homely, doesn’t it? Pumpkin pie always looks like the plain Jane standing in the corner to me. It’s not like apple pie, which can tower over the pie plate, or sport a decorative lattice. And it’s not like cherry pie, whose bright red fruit can be shockingly beautiful. No, pumpkin pie is . . . well, it’s just too brown and flat to be impressive.

And I can’t say that this pumpkin pie is really any less plain – at least on the outside. But you’ll just have to trust me when I say that it really has been spiffed up – a shot of homemade caramel gives the pumpkin a boost of sweetness, with just a hint of that bitter, burnt sugar flavor. Oftentimes I don’t like pumpkin pie because the squash tastes too healthy to me, but this tasted much more like dessert.

The verdict on this pie was mixed – I took it to kittyhagan’s pre-Thanksgiving party and, while it was well received, a full three quarters of it remained by the time I left. Granted, I gave it some pretty stiff competition, in the form of a double chocolate mint pie (more on that next week)—maybe the shy wall flower can never really compete with the beautiful cheerleader, you know?

Well, in any event, if you’re looking for a way to spice up pumpkin pie for Thursday, I definitely suggest this recipe. The caramel gives an extra boost and depth to the pumpkin filling, the crust was gloriously flaky, and, for a homely pie, it certainly packed an impressive punch of flavor. Just make sure you make it the star of the Thanksgiving dessert table, which is certainly what it deserves.

Caramel Pumpkin Pie - Party Photo

Party photo of the pie. No, I'm not telling you how much wine I had when I took this photo. Not happening.

Caramel Pumpkin Pie
Adapted from Mastering The Art of French Cooking (crust), by Julia Child, and Baking: From My Home To Yours, by Dorie Greenspan

For the pie crust
1 cup flour
1/2 tsp salt
1 tsp sugar
6 tbs unsalted butter, chilled and cut into 1/4 inch cubes
2 tbs shortening, chilled and cut into 1/4 inch cubes
1/4 cup ice water, plus a little bit more (just in case you need it).

For the caramel
1/2 cup sugar
3/4 cup heavy cream
2 tbs rum, cognac, or apple cider (or, if you are out of these ingredients and are in a pinch, 1 tbs of vanilla extract)
2 tbs unsalted butter, cut into 4 pieces

For the filling
1 cup canned unsweetened pumpkin puree
1/2 cup sugar
1 and 1/4 tsp ground cinnamon
3/4 tsp ground ginger
1/2 tsp allspice
1/2 tsp nutmeg
Pinch of salt
1 and 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
2 large eggs

For the glaze:

1 beaten egg mixed with 1 tbs of water

In a medium bowl, whisk together the flour, salt, and sugar. Place the bowl in the freezer for 15 minutes to chill. Remove bowl from freezer and add the chilled shortening and butter; cut the fat into the flour mixture using your fingers or a pastry cutter, until the fat is the size of small peas. Slowly add the cold water and stir together using a wooden spoon or spatula, until the dough just comes together. Turn dough out onto a lightly floured work surface, flatten into a disk, wrap in plastic wrap, and chill in the refrigerator for at least one hour.

Alternately, if you have a food processor: In a medium bowl, whisk together the flour, salt, and sugar. Freeze the flour mixture, butter, shortening, and the processor blade for 1/2 hour before using. Fit the blade on the processor, and then add the flour mixture, butter, and shortening to the bowl. Pulse a couple of time, in five second bursts – until the butter and shortening are the size of small peas. Add the ice water through the feeder tube – and pulse until the dough just comes together. Turn dough out onto a lightly floured work surface, flatten into a disk, wrap in plastic wrap, and chill in the refrigerator for at least one hour.

Preheat oven to 350°F.

On a lightly floured work surface, roll out one disk of the dough until it is approximately 1/8 inches thick and 1.5 inches larger than your pie pan. Transfer to pie dish and trim off excess overhanging dough with a pair of kitchen shears – leaving a 1 inch overhang. Fold over the excess dough, tucking it under itself. Crimp edge with a fork, or your fingers. Place in the refrigerator while making the filling.

In a heavy-bottomed, medium sized sauce pan, spread the 1/2 cup sugar in an even layer and heat over moderate heat (I had the most success with medium-low heat). Cook sugar until it is melted and begins to brown. Gently swirl the caramel so that it colors evenly. Continue to cook until the caramel is a deep, dark brown – this will happen quickly, so watch closely. Lower heat, stand back, and add cream – it will hiss and spatter dramatically and bits of the caramel may harden, but continue to cook until the sugar melts and the mixture is smooth. Remove from heat and add the butter and vanilla, stirring until smooth. Pour into a heatproof container and let cool for 15 minutes.

In a large bowl, whisk the pumpkin to smooth it out. Add the sugar and beat to blend. Whisk in spices, salt, vanilla, and eggs, until the mixture is smooth. Whisk in the caramel. Rap the bowl against the counter to de-bubble the filling.

Lightly brush the crimped sections of the crust with the glaze, then pour in the filling. Place in the oven for 45-50 minutes, until the filling is puffed and set. Let cool on a rack before serving. Serve with whipped cream or vanilla ice cream.



  1. Phil said

    I was searching dessert recipes for Thursday and considered an epicurious version of caramel pumpkin pie, but we decided on maple pecan pie and pumpkin cheesecake with marshmallow topping and gingersnap crust. I think I’m going to use the MTAOFC crust you suggest for the pecan pie. I’m a crust-making novice, so I’ll have to let you know how it turns out!

    • moderndomestic said

      I have also thought about making a pumpkin cheesecake – it just sounds like such a nice riff on pumpkin desserts. The only piece of advice I can stress regarding pie crust is to keep all your ingredients super cold – like, you can even whisk together the flour/sugar/salt and then place it in the freezer for 15 minutes before mixing the crust. And you can totally freeze the butter/shortening for 1/2 hour if you’re making the crust in a food processor, but if you’re mixing it with your fingers or a pastry cutter then only put it in the freezer for 15 minutes – otherwise you’ll never be able to break apart the frozen lumps of fat.

      Good luck! Those both sound like delicious desserts. Let me know how they go.

    • Lemme just tell you how it came out- AMAZING. Nice work Phil!

      • Phil said

        The cheesecake was good. I should have left the cream cheese out longer at room temperature, but I didn’t have the time to wait. The cheesecake was not ruined by any means, I just think it would have benefited from an even smoother texture.

        The pie was great! Thanks for the compliments Elena. I don’t think I will ever make a traditional pecan pie because the addition of maple syrup was perfect. The flavor was so much richer than the usual pecan-corn syrup combination that is too often cloyingly sweet.

        Most importantly, I don’t think I’ll be using a different crust recipe in the foreseeable future! Even though I may have left the pie in oven a tad too long, the crust was tender, flaky, and flavorful. It may have been overshadowed by the great filling, but I think that most people only notice when a crust is bad and just take a good crust for granted. My only issue was that I could have rolled the dough out a little more, so that I had more overhang to work with while crimping and folding the edges. Thanks for the the tips (I think freezing everything really helped) and the great recipe!

  2. […] Caramel pumpkin pie […]

  3. Kitty Hagan said

    Love the post! The pie was delicious and I think there was bit left only because we all had eaten so much turkey, stuffing and potatoes 😉

  4. Amelia said

    Hmmmmm! Well, I’m such a huge pumpkin pie fan that I can’t really imagine improving upon the basic recipe, but this is something I gotta try!

    Happy holidays, Jenna!

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: