Why Whoopie Pies Are Not the Next Cupcake

Cafe Blue Hills Tasty Treats

Are whoopie pies the next cupcake? I don't think so.

Photo by georgie_grd via flickr, under the Creative Commons license.

The New York Times is hinting that whoopie pies might be the next new big nostalgic baking trend, possibly displacing the cupcake trend. I had to give this one some thought, considering that the pioneering chockylit featured whoopie pies on her short-lived dessert blog, before disappearing  into the Internets. But Jezebel isn’t so convinced, and neither am I.

I’ve never had a whoopie pie, so I can’t judge them from a culinary perspective. They actually sound pretty tempting: two small chocolate cakes, sandwiched together with a cream filling of some kind – a precursor to the Oreo cakester.

And, although this sounds blasphemous, whoopie pies have some advantages over cupcakes. First of all, while I love frosting, too many cupcake shops pile on too much frosting for a dramatic visual effect, overwhelming the cake in the process. But because the whoopie pie is made from two pieces of cake sandwiched together with frosting, there’s a better cake-to-frosting ratio. It would also be harder to over-frost a whoopie because there’s really only so much filling one can stuff between two pieces of cake before the entire operation becomes unstable.

That being said, the idea that whoopie pies are the new cupcakes is going too far. Even if cupcakes are “trendy” now, they also occupy a large space in our collective nostalgic comfort food psyche that goes much deeper than mere trend. I would bet that every child in America—from San Franscico, to Kansas City, to Tampa—grew up eating cupcakes at birthday celebrations. We’ve all drooled at the packaged cupcakes in the pastry aisle of our local supermarkets. We’ve all seen, and probably at some time tasted, a Hostess cupcake. Cupcakes have been woven into our early childhood memories.

But whoopie pies are a regional treat, at best. According to the New York Times article, they were originally an Amish creation, and became a popular New England dessert, especially in Pennsylvania and Maine. But they aren’t ubiquitous – they are not the classic, standard childhood treat that is the cupcake.

And while the whoopie pies featured in the Times article are cute, they just aren’t as pretty as cupcakes—and it’s the cupcake’s immense artistic possibilities that are a large part of its charm. Just looking at the beautiful photos on Cupcakes Takes the Cake makes you realize that the cupcake is essentially a blank canvas which, with the aid of frosting, fondant, and sugar, can become anything imaginable. You can have cupcakes artfully decorated with shamrocks, you can make cupcakes shaped like roses, you can decorate cupcakes to look like the blood smattered smiley face pins in The Watchman. But whoopie pies, because the filling is sandwiched between two layers of cake, don’t have the same artistic possibilities. Sure, you can make them in different colors and flavors, but can you decorate them to look like Elmo? I think not.

No, the cupcake craze, if it’s going to end, isn’t over yet – and I don’t see whoopie pies posing any kind of a threat. Still, since I’ve never had them before, I believe they’ll be making an appearance at our next party. Now I just have to choose between this Epicurious recipe, or the one in the New York Times. Buttercream filling, or marshmallow fluff? Decisions, decisions.

What do you think? Is the cupcake craze at an end? Is the whoopie pie a serious contender to replace cupcakes? Have you ever made a whoopie pie?



  1. Alice said

    I have to say that the name “whoopie pie” sounds revolting to me, and for that reason alone I don’t think it’ll become a huge trend. It sounds like a cross between a bathroom humor based practical joke and sexual innuendo.

    Then again, I’ve never been able to get into cupcakes either. Too much frosting, too much cake. What I’d love to see is a tartlet craze, as pie is the superior dessert in my book.

    • moderndomestic said

      It’s because it’s too close to “whoopie cushion,” I think. And that has all kinds of associations you don’t want to make when you’re eating.

  2. Bonnie said

    The cupcake trend has barely begun here in backward Eugene. BUT, I did hear that a dedicated cupcake shop has finally opened in town. I hate it when you East Coasters declare something over before it’s reached the west.

    I grew up in Philly and never tasted a Whoopie Pie. We were reared on Tasty Kakes and never felt the need to delve into inferior things like Hostess cupcakes. Remember when we would get a big carton of Tasty Kakes in the mail from Grandma and Grandpa. Happy Days at the Huntsberger house!

  3. Kaydee said

    I made whoopie pies for a potluck the other day, they were ah-mazing. I would tweek a bit next time, too big and too much filling and the cakes were a little too moist- they probably could have cooked a smidge longer.

    AND they were actually pretty simple to make! I randomly decided to make them the night before when I was trying ot decide what to bring for a potluck that could be made in advance, I just frosted them right before I went to the party.


  4. Kaydee said

    and don’t forget that when you are making them you can cleverly say you are “making whoopie” (and whisper pies)
    🙂 good times!

  5. […] a whoopie pie revolution taking over my […]

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: